As Brian Niccol steps into the role of Chief Executive Officer at Starbucks Corp., a critical challenge looms large on his radar: navigating the complex and increasingly competitive landscape of the company’s operations in China. With a rapidly evolving market and fierce local competition, Starbucks is considering a range of strategic options, including the possibility of selling a stake in its Chinese business.
Despite China being home to nearly 20% of Starbucks’ global store count, it currently contributes less than 10% of the company’s total revenue. The impact of this disparity was evident in the company’s latest earnings report, where same-store sales in the region plummeted 14% in the third quarter, a much steeper decline than the 6% drop in the U.S.
Starbucks’ woes in China are further compounded by the explosive growth of local coffee chains, particularly Luckin Coffee Inc., which has made a remarkable recovery since its 2020 accounting scandal. Once delisted from the Nasdaq, Luckin has surged back, offering an affordable cup of coffee priced at just 9.90 yuan ($1.40) – a direct challenge to Starbucks’ core product offerings. In a country where economic uncertainty and consumer caution are rife, Luckin’s affordable pricing is winning over a growing number of coffee drinkers.
However, Luckin is not the only local competitor in Starbucks’ crosshairs. Cotti Coffee, a rival brand founded by former Luckin executives, has emerged as an even more formidable threat. Operating under a similar business model, Cotti Coffee is expanding at a rapid pace, boasting more than 10,000 stores across China – outpacing Starbucks’ 7,600 locations. Cotti’s aggressive growth strategy and its focus on low-cost, quick-service coffee appeals to a younger demographic that prioritizes affordability. The company plans to open 50,000 stores by 2025, further intensifying the price war in the Chinese market.
While Luckin’s financials are also showing signs of strain, Cotti’s expansion shows no signs of slowing down. This fierce price competition poses a challenge for Starbucks, which has struggled to compete on the same level in terms of cost and speed of growth.
For Starbucks, the key to success in China lies in expanding its reach without compromising its brand integrity. In comparison to its competitors, Starbucks operates its own stores, a model that, while offering greater control over quality and customer experience, has also slowed down the pace of its expansion. In contrast, both Luckin and Cotti Coffee heavily rely on franchising, enabling rapid store openings with significantly lower overhead costs. For young entrepreneurs eager to start their own businesses in a sluggish job market, franchising with Cotti has proven an attractive option. This has allowed the brand to grow exponentially, with new stores sprouting up in shopping malls, subways, and other high-traffic areas.
Starbucks has already started adopting this approach by expanding into smaller cities, where competition is less fierce and retail sales are generally more resilient. However, whether this strategy will be successful remains to be seen. In small towns, Starbucks’ brand allure can quickly fade as local competitors introduce similar offerings at more competitive prices.
Another significant challenge for Starbucks is the changing tastes of Chinese consumers. The company’s most popular products – Frappuccinos and sugary cold drinks – are now facing stiff competition from China’s milk-tea chains, which have captured a significant share of the market with their diverse and customizable beverages. Established brands like Chabaidao and Chagee have tapped into the trend by launching new and innovative drinks weekly, from exotic fruit blends to herbal tea concoctions, often topped with whipped cream to appeal to younger, trend-conscious drinkers. These chains have become dominant players in the market for sweet, indulgent beverages, eroding Starbucks’ once-unrivaled position.
Given these mounting challenges, many industry analysts suggest that a stake sale or strategic partnership could provide a viable path forward for Starbucks in China. Historically, restaurant chains that have spun off or sold non-core businesses have been rewarded by capital markets. For Starbucks, selling a stake in its China operations could provide the flexibility to focus on its global brand, while simultaneously allowing for a more profitable and scalable model through franchising. A sale could also free up funds for share buybacks and other growth initiatives.
Niccol is expected to visit China in early December to gain a deeper understanding of the challenges facing Starbucks in the region. If he does choose to sell a stake in the Chinese business, it would not be a retreat but rather a strategic shift. Founded in the 1970s, Starbucks must find ways to evolve and monetize its brand in China, focusing on leveraging its global appeal rather than laboriously opening new stores in a saturated and competitive market.
As Brian Niccol navigates the complexities of turning Starbucks around, China’s market will remain a key battleground. With fierce competition from local brands like Luckin and Cotti, alongside shifting consumer preferences and economic headwinds, the path forward for Starbucks will require bold and strategic decisions. A stake sale could provide the company with the flexibility it needs to adapt, innovate, and ultimately thrive in the world’s second-largest economy.
Read more:
